For more than twenty-five years the industry has told the same story: buy a CRM, train your reps, enforce discipline, and the customer insight will flow, followed by success.
It never worked.
As we discussed in our recent CRMKonvo with Nicolas Christiaen, co-founder and CEO of Donna, the most valuable customer knowledge is still created in cars, factory halls and restaurant back offices. It also still dies there. Donna's answer is an AI colleague that calls the field rep, asks how the meeting went, and then updates the CRM. That’s genuine help. And it is a far more interesting model than most vendors offer. Whether it is a cure depends on questions a buyer needs to ask before signing.
And on whether the timing is right. I presented a prototype similar to Donna to the DSAG forum in 2019 and the response was lukewarm, at best. Is the timing right now?
TL;DR
If you want to watch the full CRMKonvo, please go ahead here (optimized for smartphones) or here (optimized for tablets/computers).
Else, be my guest and continue to read.
Or do both …
The Personal Assistant Nobody Budgeted For
The origin story is telling. Nicolas sat in a taxi next to one of his best sellers, who was loudly dictating CRM updates, presentations, emails and quotes. The person on the other end of the line was Nicolas's own personal assistant, whose job description contained none of that. The top performer had simply outsourced the admin he hated to the nearest competent human.
That anecdote is important because it challenges the usual CRM adoption narrative. We keep treating poor data entry as a discipline problem among weak reps. It isn’t. Case in point: a top performing rep was the worst offender; the only reason his data made it into the system was a stolen assistant. Donna's thesis is to give every field rep, the ones driving from customer to customer, the assistant that only top sellers used to have.
The first product was a WhatsApp conversation. Then voice notes. Then proactive phone calls. Nicolas pointed out that a key lesson was variety. People differ: some reps want a call in the car, some a voice note on the walk to the car, some refuse calls altogether. Hence the "hyper-personalized" Donna with different voices, speeds and channels, plus feedback surveys during the first ninety days, because a habit that does not form in that window does not form at all.
This is the right problem to address. Field reps have rejected every screen we have thrown at them; often rightfully so. A screenless interface that follows the rep's routine is a better answer than yet another mobile CRM app. In brief: the rep was never going to adapt to the system, so the system has to adapt to the rep. it shall serve them, not the other way round.
Capture First, Advise Later
The most interesting moment came when Nicolas described Donna's early failure. The original idea was to read the CRM and tell the rep the next best action. It failed within weeks, because unsurprisingly "the data that was used as a basis was plainly wrong". It was incomplete and full of gaps. So, the team turned the product around: "We become basically the center of the capture". Donna sits on the table as a note taker, calls five minutes after the meeting, and flags holes in the next briefing.
The claim is that customers now see ten, fifteen or twenty times more data entering their system of record than before. And it is cleaner data. This makes determining the next best action become meaningful, and only with this much data does coaching actually make sense.
It is the strongest part of Nicolas’ story; it is also the part that deserves the hardest look. Volume is not quality. A tenfold increase in captured notes can be a tenfold increase in transcribed small talk, misheard product names and confident summaries of things nobody agreed on. Our own transcript of this very episode turned "Donna" into "Donner" and "CRMKonvo" into "CRM Convo". Multiply that across a sales force and your clean CRM becomes a well-populated swamp. Ralf put it kindly when he said Donna leaves the crappy legacy data for the CRM vendors to clean up. However, the simple truth is that not only the new data needs governance from day one, or the flywheel spins in the wrong direction. But it’s a start.
The pivot that Nicolas describes is the lesson for buyers. Any vendor that promises AI recommendations on top of your current CRM data is selling a recommendation engine for fiction.
Faster to the Ceiling, or Faster to Average?
There is another hard question to answer: does an AI assistant make average reps better, or just make everyone average faster? Nicolas answered with a ceiling metaphor. Everyone has a limit, and AI shortens the learning curve: juniors become mid-level sooner, mid-level reps become seniors sooner. "So, we'll just push faster to towards that ceiling."
That is an interesting, yet modest claim, more modest than most vendor pitches. But it sidesteps the deskilling risk. If preparation, debriefs and follow-ups are done for you, the muscle memory built by doing them yourself never forms. Nicolas conceded the point openly. He also argued that buyers are getting sharper, so lazy and less capable sellers will lose competitive bids.
Then there is homogenization. If the seller at one company and the seller at its competitor use the same agent, trained on similar playbooks, they become interchangeable. Nicolas's answer was three layers of differentiation: the product, the quality of the agents, and the human who builds trust. That holds only if the third layer is still being developed. An organization that cuts coaching budgets because "Donna does coaching now" removes the single one layer its competitors cannot buy.
The Coach in Your Pocket and the Manager Who Wants the Data
On the flip side, Donna already runs role plays grounded in the company's playbooks and tells reps, unprompted, how a meeting went. Reps reportedly like this because it comes from a colleague rather than the boss. That is plausible as feedback without hierarchy is easier to swallow.
The obvious next request is for that same data to feed performance appraisals. Nicolas's answer was configuration: coaching data can be switched on or off by level, and in some countries it never reaches the manager. Still, what is legal, what is legitimate and what should be done are three very different topics.
Configuration is not a policy. The moment a rep suspects the friendly AI colleague is also the manager's informant, the debrief turns into a performance and loses its value. In this case, the data quality story above collapses, because people do not confide in a system that may be used against them.
Agents Selling to Agents, and the Last Five Percent
Looking ahead, Nicolas sketched procurement agents talking to sales agents, settling the RFP matching in minutes, and leaving humans a "fill the gap" meeting for the last five percent of nuance. But then: if sixty to seventy percent of the buying process is already done before a seller is even contacted, a field assistant arrives late to the party. Something has to influence the long list earlier. Nicolas agreed that the human touch moves to the very start and the very end, and predicted that the CRM as we know it, the screen and database we train people on, will disappear into a continuously refreshed customer context.
That prediction is directionally right. It is also convenient for a company whose product is the interface replacing the screen. The system of record does not vanish because nobody looks at it. If at all, it becomes more important, because every agent on both sides of the deal reads from it. His rapid-fire pick for the CRM field to kill was the probability to close, "because everyone fills in a number that is purely based on subjective parameters". Agreed. Sort of, as that number is normally preset by the system, based on experience. And it only works if this number’s replacement is more trustworthy and reliable.
Pragmatic Playbook for Enterprise Sales and CX Buyers
AI sales assistants address a real problem, which is more than most categories can claim. If you plan to invest in one, get one on terms you can verify.
Demand quality metrics, not volume metrics. A vendor reporting ten times more CRM entries is reporting activity. Look at outcome metrics instead. Ask for error rates on extracted fields, how corrections flow back, and who audits the captured data. Whether there has been an uptick in conversions and conversion rates. Higher system adoption. Improved customer (and employee) satisfaction. Run a sample review of a hundred records against the original meetings before you scale.
Decide where coaching data goes before you deploy. Write a policy, agreed with HR and works councils where they exist, that defines whether debrief and coaching data can reach managers or appraisals. Make the vendor show you the configuration that enforces it and tell your reps what it is – even better: show it. An assistant the reps do not trust is an assistant they will feed with bogus information.
Keep humans developing the skills the agent takes over. Use the control-group approach Donna's customers often apply: a group with the assistant and one without, again, measured on outcome metrics like conversion, not just meeting counts. Then protect manager-led coaching budgets, because the human layer is your only differentiator once competitors run the same agent. If the business case depends on removing coaching, it is a cost-cutting case dressed as a productivity case.
The CRM was never short of fields. It was short of people willing to fill them. Assistants have the potential to change this.

Comments
Post a Comment